- Home
- Hobby Column
- Yukio Mishima's Bodybuilding Classroom (Part 1)
Yukio Mishima's Bodybuilding Classroom (Part 1)
◆ Yukio Mishima and Hitoshi Tamari
There is a photograph before me. It shows a man in a tank top lifting a barbell. His chest is flat, his arms are thin, and by contrast his head looks disproportionately large; what's more, the weights fitted to either end of the barbell he's lifting are quite small. This man is none other than Yukio Mishima himself, and the photograph appeared in the November 20, 1955 (Shōwa 30) issue of Shūkan Asahi, two months after he had taken up bodybuilding.
What follows has already been written about by a good many people, and is fairly well known. About two months earlier, in the summer of 1955, Mishima had noticed a piece in the Weekly Yomiuri featuring a photo of Waseda University's barbell club along with the comment, 'Anyone can get a body like this.' Without hesitation, Mishima contacted the magazine's Marumi Shiota and asked to be introduced. The man he was introduced to was Hitoshi Tamari — then a fourth-year student in Waseda's Faculty of Political Science and Economics and captain of the barbell club, who would later become chairman of the Japan Bodybuilding Federation. The two men first met in the lobby of the Nikkatsu Hotel, where Mishima was astonished to see Tamari flex his chest so that the movement was visible right through his dress shirt. Told, 'Someday, you'll look like this too,' Mishima decided on the spot to ask Tamari to train him. What's worth noting here is the condition Tamari set for the training: he would only do it if no money changed hands. Mishima, of course, was not the sort of man to argue over such a thing. The conditions he himself set in return were that Tamari should never call him 'sensei' and should simply call him by name, and that he, in turn, though eight years Tamari's senior, would call him not simply by his bare name but respectfully as 'Mr. Tamari' — a small detail that reveals just how earnestly Mishima approached learning from him.
So why did Tamari insist on doing it for free? About two years earlier, Tamari had founded the barbell club at Waseda. Members from other athletic clubs kept joining one after another to build up their strength, and by his fourth year, the club is said to have had some three hundred members. And now here was a request for training from a well-known young novelist. Tamari saw it as the perfect opportunity to spread the popularity of bodybuilding. He had thought of Mishima simply as a kind of walking advertisement, but this only further fueled Mishima's own natural tendency toward self-display, and the results ended up exceeding anyone's expectations. On December 9th of that year, Shūji Kawasaki, then Minister of Health and Welfare, was installed as chairman, and the Japan Bodybuilding Federation was founded. Tamari was involved from the very start as a managing director, and it's said that he single-handedly secured nearly all of the federation's corporate sponsors.
The immediate motive behind Mishima's taking up bodybuilding was as described above, but its underlying cause was his intense physical inferiority complex. On top of that, Mishima — who had resigned from the Ministry of Finance after only ten months to devote himself fully to writing — had settled into a routine of writing through the night and going to sleep at dawn (a habit that apparently never changed for the rest of his life). This unhealthy lifestyle brought on chronic stomach pain, and left him with a foreboding sense of anxiety about his future health.
It's also worth noting that during his travels abroad beginning in 1952, Mishima witnessed firsthand how Western writers engaged in all sorts of sports and radiated good health, and it seems fair to say that this was when his own search for better health first began.
Training took place at Mishima's home, about thirty minutes a session, three times a week, timed to start around two in the afternoon to match when Mishima woke up. On September 16, 1955, when Tamari first visited the Mishima residence, he was startled to find Mishima waiting for him already stripped down to a pair of swim trunks — pale-skinned, heavily built with body hair, yet slender and frail in build. Tamari would later recall that Mishima's physique ranked among the ten most underdeveloped of anyone he ever trained.
Even so, Mishima's father, Azusa Hiraoka, had a carpenter build a bench, and also had a barbell bar along with plates prepared. In all likelihood, they started out with a 7.5-kilogram bar fitted with 2.5-kilogram plates on either end. Mishima's starting weight was 48 kilograms, his chest measured 79 centimeters, and he stood 165.15 centimeters tall. Two months later, his weight had risen by about 2.25 kilograms, his chest had grown by about seven centimeters, and he had moved up to 5-kilogram plates, enabling him to shoulder-press 17.5 kilograms. Delighted, Mishima got in touch with Shūkan Asahi, which led to the photograph mentioned earlier.
Tamari was careful never to push the training too hard, and in any case there was only so much you could fit into thirty minutes. As far as barbell exercises go, the natural choices would have been the bench press (chest press), the shoulder press, and the barbell curl (for the biceps). If you do ten reps as one set for each of the chest, shoulders, and arms, with a two-minute rest between sets, and repeat that for three or four sets, thirty minutes disappears easily. Abdominal training was probably left as homework, since it's the one kind of training you can do every single day. Mishima came to love this particular homework more than anything — a fact one can infer from how, in later years, he took to calling himself 'Mr. Abs.'
It's said that ordinary muscles need about forty-eight hours to recover from training, while larger muscle groups — the back and the thighs — need as long as seventy-two hours. Training done at home couldn't really cover the latter, so a schedule of three sessions a week made good practical sense. Even with training this modest, Mishima later recalled that for the first session or two he had to crawl up the stairs on all fours and plaster his entire back with medicated patches; and for the first several months, he was apparently plagued by fevers of unknown cause and swollen tonsils. This was probably the result of what was, relatively speaking, a fairly heavy load placed on a frail body with essentially no history of exercise, which weakened his immune system enough to bring on fever — a reaction that, apparently, sometimes occurs in women with little exercise experience as well, a kind of defensive instinct rejecting the exertion. After this, Mishima's appetite returned, and he switched from two meals a day to three.
After every training session, the two of them would always sit down to a lavish lunch cooked by Mishima's mother, Shizue. And whenever there was time to spare, Mishima would take Tamari out to Ginza and treat him to a meal. For drinks, they'd go to Peter's in the Sanshin Building, or the bar at the Imperial Hotel. From time to time, Mishima would present Tamari with a cashmere sweater, a vest, or a necktie, and he also took him along to the Writers' Club, the Nissei Theatre, and the movies — his own particular way of showing real consideration and gratitude toward Tamari, who never once accepted payment.
There's an amusing episode from this period that captures Mishima well. It was probably around the time he traveled to Kyoto to research The Temple of the Golden Pavilion. Forced to stay several days for his research, he naturally found himself unable to train, and — flustered — he got in touch with Tamari for guidance. The result was that he had dumbbells procured and delivered to his lodgings, and trained right there. It's a small glimpse of just how meticulous and disciplined Mishima could be.
◆ Yukio Mishima in 1956
Half a year after training began, Tamari graduated from university, bringing his sessions with Mishima to an end. Around that time, Mishima placed a joking advertisement in the 'Shūkan Shinchō Bulletin Board' column of Shūkan Shinchō, February 19, 1956:
Wish to establish a Literary World Bodybuilding Association. Recruiting members. Frail novelists only. Would like to ask Mr. Yasunari Kawabata to serve as chairman. Current membership: myself alone. Office: the bodybuilding dojo in the garden of the Mishima residence.
Naturally, no members ever came forward — nor, presumably, did Mishima ever really expect any to. Around the same time, in an interview titled 'A Novelist's Twenty-Four Hours,' he gave the following answer:
This barbell looks deceptively light, but it's actually 17.5 kilograms. What I'm doing here is repeatedly lifting it overhead, an exercise called the behind-the-neck press. Little by little, I'm starting to look the part — or rather, I suppose you'd say I'm getting the hang of the bar.
Judging from this article, Mishima doesn't seem to have changed all that much from the photo taken the previous November — he's handling the same weight, though back in November he probably couldn't yet manage ten reps of it. The behind-the-neck press is a shoulder exercise in which the barbell is raised and lowered behind the head, placing more load on the shoulder than either the overhead or front shoulder press. That said, for anyone with even a little training experience, this particular weight wouldn't even qualify as a warm-up.
Mishima later spoke of this period in his essay 'A Sports Theory Based on Experience,' published in the Yomiuri Shimbun in October 1964:
If you ask me what's genuinely interesting in this world, there is nothing quite so interesting as watching your own strength grow, day by day. It is one of the most essential joys a human being can know.
Bodybuilding, being an exercise invented in America of all places, is put together in an extremely rational, logical way in every respect, gradually increasing the weight over time to remake the body. Even so, I grew a little impatient along the way — imitating a young friend of mine, I suddenly started drinking five gō of milk a day and upset my stomach, and I once downed an entire jar of American high-protein powder and gave myself indigestion. Muscle development through bodybuilding shows its most dramatic results only when begun around the age of twenty, during that peak period of muscular development while the bones too are still growing — and there's no denying that starting in your thirties puts you at a considerable disadvantage. And yet, after about half a year, I found myself doubting my own eyes at the sight of a body that had become one I was no longer ashamed to show in public. In my younger days, I had believed that self-consciousness and muscle were absolute opposites, utterly irreconcilable — and now I found myself marveling at this miracle, by which an extreme form of self-consciousness was itself cultivating muscle. This was at once one of the greatest inventions of American culture, and a symbol of American culture's own paradox.
First, I want to point out that this passage was written nine years after Mishima had first taken up bodybuilding, and that it presents both a good side and a bad side side by side. The good side is how quickly Mishima kept up with information. Around 1955, the momentum behind weight training in America was just beginning to take off in earnest, and it was around this time that Muscle Builder and Mr. America — the magazines that were the direct predecessors of Muscle & Fitness, founded by Joe Weider, the man behind the now-famous 'Weider' brand — were enjoying real popularity (Arnold Schwarzenegger would not make his first appearance in its pages until the July 1968 issue). Mishima placed a newspaper advertisement trying to get hold of what we would today simply call protein powder, but without success. He ran the following notice in the 'Shūkan Shinchō Bulletin Board' column of Shūkan Shinchō, June 19, 1956:
Thanks to bodybuilding, my once-frail shoulders and chest are almost unrecognizable now, but I still haven't put on nearly enough weight. I saw an advertisement in an American bodybuilding magazine for a supplement that promised to add three kan (about eleven kilograms) of weight in two months, so I inquired at every single foreign pharmacy in Tokyo and Yokohama, but couldn't find it anywhere. If anyone knows where I might find it, please get in touch. The product is called 'Weight-Gaining Liquid,' or alternatively 'Quick Wate.'
As it happened, a company that later began selling protein supplements ended up using Mishima's little advertisement itself as free publicity. It's a small glimpse of just how unhesitatingly Mishima kept up with American newspapers and magazines.
Now for the bad side. His claim about the handicap of training in your thirties doesn't really hold up today. Building a bodybuilder's physique is not something achieved in just a few years, and top competitors in their twenties are actually quite rare — it's a world dominated by people in their forties and fifties. Of course, the training effects one gets in one's twenties are remarkable, but the tendency for that muscle to actually develop real bulk tends to happen only from one's thirties onward. And speaking from my own experience, even starting in one's thirties, growth can be dramatic, and I never really felt any such handicap.
There's another passage that makes me tilt my head in doubt: the claim that, half a year after starting training, his body was already 'no longer something to be ashamed of in public.' Given training of only about thirty minutes, three times a week, and taking the two-month results into account, we're probably talking about a body weight of fifty kilograms (which barely changed after this), a chest of around ninety centimeters, and a barbell load that had grown ten kilograms over four months to about thirty kilograms — a weight well within reach of an ordinary adult male beginner. His physique at that point was surely still a far cry from the Mishima of later years, but since he was writing about events nine years in the past, it seems likely that, having grown so used to his later body, the difference from his earlier self had simply become hazy to him. This is also suggested by Yasushi Imamura — who trained alongside Mishima at the same Sankei Building gym — in his book The Real Face of Yukio Mishima, where he remarks that even three years into training, Mishima's body remained small in stature, without a great deal of muscle to show for it.
That spring, Mishima joined a gym in Jiyūgaoka run by a man named Tomoo Suzuki. Mishima would later recall him as a former naval marine calisthenics instructor — foul-mouthed in the extreme, sunny and cheerful, extremely dogmatic, fiercely competitive, and, as a bodybuilding coach, deeply opposed to the whole philosophy of bodybuilding. Mishima goes on:
According to his theory, in order to keep the muscle built through bodybuilding from stiffening up, one needs to combine it with flexibility exercises — Danish Bukh gymnastics, that sort of thing — and stretching movements, and so at that gym I found myself, of all things, brought face to face once more with the very naval calisthenics I'd done back in high school. The very same exercises I had once done grudgingly during the war, I now did, if I exaggerate only a little, with tears of pure joy streaming down my face. (...)
His slogan, something like 'Physical education, woven into daily life,' is now something I find myself preaching to other people in exactly his own tone of voice, and his theory — that to balance out bodybuilding, which mainly works the flexor muscles, one must always pair it with some kind of extensor exercise — has determined every choice I've made about sport ever since.
Tomoo Suzuki placed real emphasis on flexibility exercises rooted in naval calisthenics, and weight training seems to have been very much a secondary concern for him. Today, the importance of stretching is widely recognized — there's even a school of thought holding that one should spend more time stretching than actually lifting weights. In that sense, one could say that Mishima was fortunate, early in his training life, to have found two genuinely excellent mentors in Tamari and Suzuki.
In his essay 'A Philosophy of Bodybuilding,' published in Manga Yomiuri, September 20, 1956, Mishima writes:
This September marks one year since I began bodybuilding. Aside from one three-week break when I caught a cold, I've kept at it faithfully. I originally took up this exercise to shake off my physical inferiority complex, and that complex has healed the way one peels away thin sheets of paper, one by one — until now I'm very nearly cured of it entirely.
People looking at me from the outside would probably still say I don't have much of a physique — but as long as I subjectively feel my own build is a good one, that's all that matters.
When I think about what good it ever did me to carry this kind of inferiority complex around for thirty years, it strikes me as utterly absurd. (...)
It's a widely held belief that physical vigor and spiritual beauty are absolutely incompatible. (...) That may be well and good as a symbol, or as conventional wisdom, but the real question is what actually happens to the person in question. The human body and spirit do not sit still like symbols; they are in constant flux, in a state of perpetual becoming. When the balance between body and spirit breaks down, whichever side gains the upper hand gradually devours the one that's lost ground. The thin man becomes too intellectual; the fat man becomes too impulsive. Every unhappiness of modern civilization arises, without exception, from this same imbalance. (...)
On the one hand, there are writers who are too intellectual, or else too given over to pure sensation. (...)
Somewhere in their work, there is always a lack of any solid, tangible impression of flesh. What's missing is the very radiance of the flesh — true sensuality itself. (...)
This, precisely, is the shortcoming of modern art. The intellect alone has developed to an abnormal degree, while the flesh has failed to keep pace with it. (...)
To me, the flesh seems like an expression of the intellect's own shyness, or its own humility. The sharper the intellect, the more it needs to be wrapped in flesh. (...)
Try bodybuilding, if only just to see — trust me on this. Mind you, I recommend it above all for my fellow intellectuals; if a man with an empty head takes up bodybuilding on top of that, all he does is reinforce his own imbalance, which is a thoroughly pointless exercise.
A year after taking up bodybuilding, Mishima's state of mind seems to have amounted to something far more than simply having a healthier body and getting more work done. In the very process by which his physical inferiority complex dissolved, his thinking began to grasp what he called 'the balance between body and spirit.' He addresses this same idea from another angle in his essay 'Literature and Sport,' published in Shintaiiku in October 1956. There, he admits that his own thinking, before he took up bodybuilding, had equated physical activity with mental activity, and that he had been writing novels as though writing itself were a kind of sport — a mistake, he now realized, that arose from failing to understand the difference between the fatigue that comes from writing a novel and the physical fatigue that comes from sport. He writes:
More and more, I found that the fatigue after bodybuilding actually spurred my writing on, and that the fatigue of the writing itself, the next morning, was in turn soothed away by bodybuilding. (...)
As a result, within me, mental and spiritual fatigue and physical fatigue came to be clearly distinguished from one another. (...) I lost all desire to write the kind of novel that chases after pure sensation, straining the nerves, written with the sheer force of the body. More and more, within me, the novel became work that belonged to the intellectual domain. (...)
These days, I think of it this way: what a writer truly needs for his work is a clear, transparent awareness of physical health — without it, a novelist could never summon the courage to descend into the dark abyss of human nature. (...)
And so, at the risk of sounding a little dogmatic, I have come to think of art, for me, as a kind of hygiene for sport, and sport, for me, as a kind of hygiene for art. The two must be kept in balance with one another, and yet it seems to me that the more pronounced their apparent imbalance, the deeper the resulting work may become. Beyond bodybuilding, I intend to try my hand at all sorts of sports from here on.
Here Mishima takes his thinking a step further than in 'A Philosophy of Bodybuilding.' He now argues that it is precisely a spirit supported by a clear, transparent awareness of physical health that can descend into the dark abyss of human nature. And the final piece of rhetoric here is a fascinating one: 'the more pronounced the imbalance between art and sport, the deeper the resulting novel becomes.' This would seem to let us substitute 'spirit and body' for 'art and sport' — and yet nowhere in this passage does Mishima point toward an imbalance in the sense of spirit swelling larger than body. In that scenario, after all, it is precisely the radiance of the flesh, true sensuality itself, that gets excluded as lacking. What Mishima is placing his hopes in here is, rather, the opposite imbalance — the body vastly outstripping the spirit. Only about a year after taking up bodybuilding, what stands out is not so much the improvement in his physical strength as the remarkable degree to which his consciousness had been awakened — and this is precisely the thread that leads onward to Sun and Steel.