Director's Column

Director's Column vol.2 ● The Value of a Single Tooth

What I feel again and again in my day-to-day clinical work is just how much value a single tooth can carry. Back when I was a green associate dentist working in a rundown part of Yokohama, a young Southeast Asian woman once came in for treatment. She had no health insurance card, and the Japanese man who came along with her, and who didn't exactly inspire confidence, acted as her interpreter. Thinking vaguely that she must have come to work in a country whose language she didn't even speak, I tried asking about her chief complaint (the thing bothering her most) using gestures and broken English. Partly because I didn't want to go through the interpreter — who looked like the sort of person who might be skimming something off the top — I tried communicating with her directly, and learned that she had pain in her upper left back tooth. When I examined it, the decay had almost exposed the nerve. I told her the tooth could be treated with a root canal and restored, but she said she couldn't come in for that many visits. Looking in her mouth again, I found several other missing teeth as well. Her request, in order to finish everything in a single visit, was simply to have the tooth extracted. Because she fell outside Japan's insurance system, I ended up in the position of having to help make the condition of her mouth worse, of all things. As a mere associate dentist, I obviously couldn't offer to treat her for free (I could just picture the director's furious face), so, with real reluctance, I remember pulling the tooth. Now that I run my own practice, it's not really a dilemma any more, as long as I'm willing to treat someone for free when it's called for. Something similar can easily happen with Japanese patients who have no insurance card too, though each case does need to be judged on its own. That clinic where I worked also happened to be the designated facility for handling emergency cases among unconvicted detainees held at the nearby police station, and I ended up "treating" (if you can call it that) a few of them. One day, the police station called to say they wanted to bring someone in during the lunch break, apparently timed for when there would be no other patients around. He came escorted by three detectives. They first asked where the exits were, and stationed two officers at the two doorways. When I asked the remaining one whether there was any chance the man might run, he said it should be fine, since the man had turned himself in. Looking inside his mouth, where he had pain, I found ten teeth reduced to bare roots (with no crown remaining). When I suggested to the detective that we split the extractions across a few visits, he brushed the idea aside, saying it had been hard enough just to get the man out for this one visit. So I asked the handcuffed man himself whether it would be alright to pull all ten today, and he said he didn't mind. Well, it's not as if I'm the one who'd feel the pain, I thought, and went ahead and gave him the anesthetic. While waiting for it to take effect, I asked the detective, "Do you carry a gun with you, even on an errand like this?" "Yes, I have it on me." "Would you mind letting me take a look?" "No — it's too dangerous." "Just a peek? I'm not exactly enjoying this job myself, you know." "Rules are rules." That request, too, was flatly turned down. Afterward I was told the man had ten prior convictions, so I covered as much of my own face as I could with a mask and went ahead with the extractions — though he gave up around the sixth tooth. These days, with a clientele in a fairly comfortable location, I rarely have such unusual experiences, but the one disappointing thing is that, with everyone in society apparently so busy, it's still hard to get people to take my advice to spend fifteen to twenty minutes brushing at night, if not necessarily in the morning and at midday, and to use floss or an interdental brush as well. Once you've actually lost a tooth, it's too late to wish you'd brushed more. Please stay mindful of just how fortunate it is to be able to chew with your own natural teeth.

Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi