- Home
- Director's Column
- Director's Column vol.1: Why No Insurance-Covered Denture?
Director's Column vol.1: Why No Insurance-Covered Denture?
"Dentists never seem willing to make you a denture under insurance." Quite a few patients voice this complaint. Just the other day, a conversation with a patient touched on exactly this. And the reasons behind it don't seem to be widely understood, either. I run my own practice here in Tokyo, and of course I do make insurance-covered dentures — so I'd like to think through those reasons here.
First, let's take as a case study a patient with no teeth remaining in the upper jaw, and assume the lower jaw needs no treatment. On the first visit, I listen to the chief complaint, carry out an examination, and take impressions of the upper and lower ridges (the gum ridges) and the bite. Based on that, I make an individual tray for the upper jaw (an impression tool made of plastic) myself, or send the job out to a lab. The next day, I take a precise, detailed impression of the upper ridge — a step that a good many dentists actually skip. Based on that, I make (or send out to a lab) an occlusal rim (a device made of plastic and wax). On the third day, using that, I check the height of the bite and the patient's facial appearance; or, if the front-to-back positioning of the bite is uncertain, I take a check-bite (a test to restore the bite to how it was when the natural teeth were still there) — in which case this step moves to the fourth day. On the fourth day, I try in the wax setup with the artificial teeth arranged on it (prepared by the lab) to check the general bite and how the mouth and face look. On the fifth day, I fit the finished denture, sent back from the lab, onto the patient and check the bite and whether there are any sore spots anywhere on the gums. If it seems usable, I have the patient wear it for a while first, then have them come back the next day or the day after for adjustment. After that, if problems remain, I repeat the adjustment as many times as needed. That's roughly the process, and even at a minimum it takes seven or eight visits. In terms of insurance revenue, this comes to somewhere around ¥40,000–47,000, of which the lab costs average ¥15,000–20,000 (that's the difference in price depending on whether I make the individual tray and occlusal rim myself). And for any adjustments after the fitting day, no matter how many times the patient comes back, all I can bill is the follow-up consultation fee (¥380). That is the full procedure and cost breakdown for making a denture under the insurance system. And if you divide that ¥20,000–30,000 in revenue across seven or eight sessions of about thirty minutes each, it adds up to a job that simply doesn't pay well. By comparison, if I fill a tooth with resin (plastic), I can do at least two teeth in thirty minutes, which comes to ¥5,000–7,000; and if I have a hygienist take over the filling and polishing partway through, the insurance revenue comes to two or three times that. In that sense, too, denture work simply doesn't pay. As a result, dentists tend to become reluctant to do anything beyond patching up an existing denture — and, on top of that, denture repairs themselves aren't bad money at all.
At present there's no move underway to raise the insurance fee schedule for dentures, and with the overall budget for insurance treatment capped as it is, the balance would be difficult to maintain in any case. I do think the system itself ought to be reconsidered, but when you look at the bigger picture of national medical spending (dental treatment accounts for only around ten percent of that total), pushing narrow, self-interested demands doesn't sit entirely right with me either — and honestly, even a 20–30% increase in the fee wouldn't really change the underlying situation. My own reason for continuing to make insurance-covered dentures is simple: I graduated from a national university, and my education was paid for in large part with public tax money (though of course a fair share of the budget goes to private universities too). To be honest, I feel that if you're going to hang out a sign as an insurance-registered dentist and then turn around and say you won't make an insurance-covered denture, you rather deserve to have your character called into question. Let me close with a favorite saying from my own mentor in dentistry: "Even a supermarket keeps a few discounted, loss-leading items out on its shelves. If you insist that every single treatment has to turn a profit, doesn't that make a dentist worse than a supermarket?"
Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi