Director's Column

Director's Column vol.3 ● How to Choose a Good Dentist

I was given the topic "how to choose a good dentist." It's a bit of a difficult one, because how much a patient does or doesn't expect from treatment varies enormously from person to person. Up to the point of simply relieving the pain of an acute symptom, there probably isn't much difference between one dentist and another (and to begin with, plenty of people never let things get that far, thanks to daily care) — but after that, some people simply stop coming once the pain is gone. Almost always, if you look inside their mouth, you'll find several teeth reduced to bare roots, and even if you schedule their next appointment, they won't show up. But let's set that digression aside and not muddy the question further; let's speak in general terms and think instead about people who never neglect their dental care and who are looking for the best possible treatment, even if it costs a bit more. Lately I've been receiving a lot of direct-mail solicitations from organizations calling themselves dental-practice management consultants, offering to run a "business diagnosis." Buried in their pitch is usually a list of what supposedly makes a "good" dental clinic: that it's clean and tidy, that you should check the restroom, how the front desk staff respond to you, the latest equipment, listening closely to the patient and giving explanations they can actually understand, and so on. I understand the appeal of each point, but I can't quite shake the feeling that something about it rings a little hollow. For one thing, some of that can simply be bought with money. Are we really meant to believe that a clinic should take out a loan to renovate, if it doesn't already have the funds to spare, and then pass that cost straight on to patients through their treatment fees? Another thing I often hear is that clinics that have spent heavily on their premises tend to dislike patients who only carry national insurance. That's because the average monthly insurance revenue per patient in Tokyo runs at roughly ¥15,000, so if you take a storefront clinic in the middle of the city, or one that's landed a spot in some large building through connections, paying rent of, say, ¥50,000 per tsubo (a unit of roughly 3.3 square meters) for forty tsubo, that works out to about 130 patients' worth of revenue disappearing into rent alone — and of course there are other expenses on top of that. Under those conditions, is it really realistic to expect careful, attentive treatment for patients on insurance alone? I once worked at a clinic in Otemachi with about the best location money could buy; its profits were more than healthy (it had as many as eight associate dentists on staff), yet it also squeezed its dental lab down to rock-bottom prices and used the cheapest metals available. A beautiful clinic and the quality of the crowns and other restorations that actually go into your mouth simply aren't correlated. It's only natural for a patient to feel anxious on a first visit, so a reassuring manner at the front desk is certainly necessary. But even though I know a young, attractive receptionist can help draw in patients, I have no interest in taking that approach myself — there's no point in selling a clinic on flash and appearances. So is there really a way to choose well? I believe there is. Drawing up the right treatment plan for a patient's particular condition is a matter of the practitioner's knowledge, experience, and judgment; treating patients properly and consistently, whether insured or private-pay, is a matter of the clinic's finances and conscience. Some clinics, however shabby they may look on the outside (within reason), quietly aim to provide solid treatment at a fair price even on thin margins, while other dentists set up in a prime location, pour in capital, and think of the whole thing purely as a business to be recouped. So is there really no way to filter between the two? I think there is. First, explain your own symptoms clearly and thoroughly. Then ask what your treatment options are. If, at that point, the dentist listens patiently and explains the range of possible treatments, you're probably in good hands — but if the conversation quietly slides into whether it's covered by insurance or not, that's a red flag. And if a dentist simply has you open your mouth and starts cutting or removing things without a word of explanation, you'd do better to say you'd rather not have anything done today and leave. A dentist who tells you plainly what's being done today, and who takes real pride in their work, should be willing to explain things as thoroughly as you need. So don't be shy about asking every persistent question you can think of, and pay attention to how they respond.

Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi