Hobby Column

Front Row: Laurence Anyways (Dolan), Part 1

◆ A Word Before We Begin: The Foreshadowing in the Prologue

Whenever someone recommends a film by some young director nobody's ever heard of, I think everyone eyes the DVD with a bit of suspicion before deciding whether it's worth picking up. I felt much the same way, but the person making the recommendation was Asami Shibuya, an actress with an unrivaled love of film, so I decided to trust her judgment.

She'd already seen every film Xavier Dolan had made, and the one she recommended above all the rest was Laurence Anyways — his third feature, made in 2012 when he was just twenty-three.

The opening alone is fascinating. It's one close-up after another of ordinary people out in the city. They do almost nothing you'd call acting — it's as though their faces alone are saying something. I'd seen this kind of scene once before, in Pier Paolo Pasolini's The Gospel According to St. Matthew. When Pasolini rolls out one frontal close-up after another like that, you can't help but marvel at how painterly some of those faces are — as if they'd walked straight out of a Bosch or a Bruegel. And yet, almost without exception, they represent the Antichrist's ignorant masses, or people who haven't yet found faith — and that act of categorizing them was itself the silent performance. It's said that Pasolini arrived at this technique simply because he began shooting without really knowing how to make a film. So what is Laurence Anyways itself showing us in its own opening? In the next scene, a tall, big-boned woman in a tight suit strides forward. Her hair streams out behind her, but her face keeps almost — never quite — coming into view. If you're watching closely, you'll notice this is really the film's true introduction, and it ends leaving you with the sense that something is about to happen.

The scene changes: a bare-chested man stands in the kitchen, lost in thought, smoking a cigarette while sipping from a glass of sparkling water he's nearly spilled — as if it, too, were saying that nothing in life ever goes quite smoothly. Beside him hangs a page-a-month calendar, and we can make out that it's November 1989 — the very month the Berlin Wall fell. No doubt many Europeans felt, in that moment, that they'd been freed from the old regimes and ideologies. And yet this man, indifferent to all the commotion outside, is completely absorbed in his own private thoughts. In the film's bonus features, Xavier Dolan explains that he deliberately chose this moment of liberation on purpose — because the last remaining stronghold was transsexuality, and the world in that moment simply wasn't ready to understand it yet.

Just from these two choices alone, you can't really describe Xavier Dolan as a director working purely on youthful instinct. He clearly knows the grammar of cinema inside and out — calling him already a seasoned hand wouldn't be an exaggeration. And both scenes, as it turns out, are foreshadowing. If you keep watching and later think back on these two scenes, you'll realize — though it's handled so subtly that it's easy to miss — that together they're quietly preparing us for the fact that "Laurence wants to become a woman": the first scene speaks to the discomfort and unease that fact stirs up in other people, and the second to just how intensely private that realization is for Laurence.

Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi