- Home
- Director's Column
- Director's Column Vol. 22: The State of Implant Treatment, Part 2
Director's Column Vol. 22: The State of Implant Treatment, Part 2
Continuing on from last time, I would like to say more about the situation surrounding implant treatment. After the question of materials, the next issue is price. These days, a search online turns up some surprisingly cheap offers, but many of these simply make up the difference elsewhere, through steep charges for options and maintenance, and in more than a few cases you have to wonder where the implant itself was even made, or how well the crown that sits on top of it was actually crafted. The going rate generally seems to be somewhere around ¥350,000–¥400,000 for a complete implant restoration. What's interesting, though, is how that fee often seems to be set: apparently, quite a few clinics simply take the direct costs — the implant fixture itself, plus the materials and lab fees for the crown — and multiply by five. No small number of dentists will tell you that once you factor in the cost of surgical equipment and instruments, sterilization, and general overhead, the margin isn't really all that generous. But isn't that really just the thinking of a small shopkeeper? For one thing, it overlooks the effect of scale — deliberately, one suspects. If a clinic only handles a few cases a year, then even after spending several million yen to set up a surgical system for implants, depreciation will barely progress and profit margins will stay low. But once a clinic is handling several dozen cases or more, the picture reverses, and costs move ever closer to the direct costs alone. Ordinarily, once that initial investment has been paid off, a business would be expected to lower its prices in order to stay competitive. And yet that doesn't seem to be how things are thought about here.
Next, consider the surgical environment that implant treatment calls for. To maintain a semi-sterile setting, a clinic is expected to have a properly equipped operating room, an air cleaner to remove airborne bacteria, and monitoring equipment for use during surgery. How much of this the average private practice can actually provide, though, is another matter. On top of that, positioning an implant three-dimensionally — taking into account the direction of the dental arch and the thickness and shape of the jawbone — really cannot be done with two-dimensional X-rays alone; a dental CT scanner is essential. Yet few clinics install one, since the equipment costs roughly ¥30 million. As a workaround, there are imaging centers that will perform a scan on a clinic's behalf for just under ¥30,000, but caught between concerns over safety and cost, the reality is that most clinics still don't make use of them.
Finally, there is the question of maintenance. After implant treatment, regular recall visits for follow-up are essential. This also assumes a certain minimum standard of home oral hygiene on the patient's part, because the gum tissue sandwiched between the implant fixture and the jawbone is, by its nature, in a somewhat pathological state to begin with. There is a condition called peri-implantitis: unlike a natural tooth, which is protected by attached gingiva, the tissue around an implant is a site of more or less continuous inflammation. So if home care is inadequate, the jawbone around the embedded implant can begin to resorb, and in the worst cases the implant becomes mobile and eventually falls out. When such warning signs appear, the crown has to be removed and the patient must go through surgical treatment all over again. What's more, while the core age group receiving implant treatment is currently in their fifties, that average keeps trending older. As it does, there has not yet been enough discussion about how we can care for patients who, in their final years, are no longer able to maintain their implants on their own — and that remains a challenge for the future.
Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi