- Home
- Director's Column
- Director's Column Vol. 21: The State of Implant Treatment, Part 1
Director's Column Vol. 21: The State of Implant Treatment, Part 1
One statistic often cited as evidence of the rise of implant treatment is that membership in the Japanese Society of Oral Implantology has passed 10,000. Given that there are roughly 95,000 dentists in clinical practice nationwide, that proportion suggests implant treatment has been steadily gaining acceptance within the profession. Not every dental school offers it, but a number of them have now established dedicated courses, complete with lectures and hands-on training, for their students.
So why has implant treatment spread so quickly? The first reason is the advance of the treatment technology itself. This has been matched by aggressive marketing from manufacturers, and, on the patient side, by growing understanding of implant treatment, which has come to be recognized as a genuine option and has, in turn, fueled demand for a higher standard of oral care. From the dentist's perspective, a growing number of dentists has meant fewer patients to go around, while NHI-covered treatment has been kept under continual downward pressure — dentistry accounts for a mere 7.6% of Japan's total national medical expenditure (as of fiscal 2006) — and together these have created a sense of being boxed in by insurance treatment, and, conversely, a growing appetite for the far higher fees that implant treatment can command.
Statistically speaking, the typical age for implant treatment is the fifties, and that average has recently been trending older. Given that, what should we be paying attention to?
First, I want to consider the materials used for the upper structure — the visible, tooth-like part that sits on top of the implant fixture. The fixture itself is essentially screw-shaped, and it is turned into the jawbone as it is placed. A natural tooth, although it too is embedded in the jawbone, is cushioned and protected by the periodontal ligament. An implant, embedded directly into the bone, has no such cushion. As a result, it takes the full impact of chewing forces directly, which is why all-ceramic crowns so often chip at the occlusal surface (the biting surface). Practitioners who want to avoid this often turn instead to a high-karat gold crown (20K): gold is soft enough to wear down gradually rather than chip, and it is gentler on the opposing teeth as well. Aesthetically, though, its yellowish tone isn't popular with many patients. A compromise is to make the biting surface out of metal while keeping the buccal, or front-facing, surface white — using a hard resin or similar material — though on the lower jaw the metal tends to show, which plenty of patients dislike. When a patient wants the crown to be white all over, there are hybrid materials available: they contain filler particles, have some elasticity, and wear down at a moderate rate, which makes them gentler on the opposing teeth than ceramic. Because hybrid materials are cheaper than ceramic, some dentists hesitate to recommend them, but demand for them has been growing. Still, when it comes purely to aesthetics, nothing beats ceramic. Building up the crown in layered porcelain allows it to be shaped almost however one likes, and because the color is built up directly within the porcelain, even subtle gradations of shade are entirely achievable.
Because this crown sits on an implant, however, it needs to make very even contact with the opposing teeth, which limits the shapes it can take. It also tends not to wear down the way natural teeth do over the years — ceramic is so hard that it tends to chip rather than wear, which is a real concern. Even so, patients who prioritize appearance still tend to ask for ceramic. Hybrid crowns aren't bad when it comes to color, but they still fall a little short of ceramic, although with a sufficiently skilled dental technician, that gap can disappear almost entirely. And if a hybrid crown does chip, it's easier to repair than ceramic. As the materials keep improving, I expect hybrid crowns will be used more and more. Finally, there is zirconia: extremely hard, and well suited to the front teeth, though it does seem to fracture wherever it's especially thin, and its shade still leaves something to be desired. I would like to continue this discussion next time.
Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi