- Home
- Director's Column
- Director's Column Vol. 17: The Pitfall of a Good Explanation
Director's Column Vol. 17: The Pitfall of a Good Explanation
The other day, while having a drink at a bar I frequent, I happened to overhear the owner talking to a customer. "That's what I always say — I can't tell you what to recommend until I know what you like and what you don't. Once I know that, I'll line up some bottles for you; the prices are right there on a label on the back, and if you'd like a detailed explanation of any of them, I'm happy to give one. I try to offer good bottles as cheaply as I can, since I price them based on what I paid for them, so some of them are quite a bargain." He was in the middle of explaining a single malt whisky. "Just tell me sweet or dry, firm or soft, and I'll pour accordingly — from there, you can go backward or forward from that starting point. I like to line the bottles up in chronological order, and I don't carry too many from the smaller distilleries, so once they're lined up, if you just tell me roughly where to start, it should be easy to follow." I'd heard this little speech from him many times before, but it really is a sound, well-reasoned way of putting things, and every time I hear it, I'm struck again by how easy it makes things for the listener to follow. Mind you, the customer seemed a little taken aback by such a tidy, systematic explanation, and didn't seem quite as impressed as I was. Listening to this exchange, I found myself thinking about my own work. Before you even get to the range of possible treatments, there is the range of the patient's symptoms, and it's really that, more than anything, that determines the treatment. Put plainly: extract the tooth, or keep it — and if you keep it, remove the nerve, or prepare it without doing so. Only after that initial decision does real variety come in: what to fill it with, what to crown it with, or what kind of appliance to use instead. What we have to be careful about here is that the choice of treatment is not something left up to whim. A tooth is only extracted when it has become too mobile — side to side, front to back, or up and down — to withstand normal biting forces, or when, even after root canal treatment, the crown of the tooth has broken down so badly that a core can no longer be placed in it. Likewise, the nerve is only removed when the pulp is already exposed, or when, even after the decayed portion has been removed and covered over with cement, the pain simply will not settle down. The dentist is obliged to make that threshold clear to the patient, though I have to say this isn't always the case in practice. When it isn't, the wise course is to pause treatment and seek a second opinion elsewhere. I've said this before more than once, but as implant treatment has become more widespread, I've increasingly come across cases where saving a natural tooth is given too little weight. The dilemma facing any dental practice is that treatment and business are inseparable, and that is precisely where the temptation to recommend expensive treatment creeps in. I understand the temptation to recommend an implant — extracting the tooth and charging several times as much — rather than committing to patient, painstaking root canal work or the ongoing maintenance of a loose tooth with advanced gum disease. But a diagnosis has nothing to do with how much money is at stake, and simply giving an honest diagnosis ought to be the most basic obligation of any dentist registered to provide NHI-covered treatment. And yet the great majority of patients who come to me from other clinics have, at some point, been advised to replace a perfectly savable tooth with an implant. It's something I want to keep firmly in mind: that when individual dentists squander their patients' trust, it is ultimately the credibility of the whole profession that suffers.
As for the restorations placed after treatment — fillings and crowns — there are, broadly speaking, NHI-covered options and private, self-pay options. Even within NHI-covered restorations, although regulations govern the proportion of palladium the metal must contain, some clinics still use inferior alloys to pad their margins. It might be worth asking, even for an NHI-covered restoration, exactly what metal is being used — if you're told it contains 12% palladium, you should be in good hands. For private treatment, ask to have the relationship between the price and what you're actually getting explained to you, and if the cost is high, it's worth not deciding on the spot: go home, search online, and compare other clinics first. A clinic that is confident in its work will never be reluctant to give you a thorough explanation.
Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi