Director's Column

Director's Column vol.16: A Contrived Diagnosis

I recently saw a patient, referred by someone else, in a situation like this. On the upper left, the back four teeth had already been extracted—supposedly because they 'wouldn't last'—and nothing had been done about it since. On the right side, the fourth tooth (the first premolar) was mid-treatment; the fifth and seventh were merely 'scheduled' for treatment and had simply been left to crumble away in the meantime; and the sixth tooth was already missing. When the patient said that, since she couldn't chew at all like this, she would at least like a temporary crown made for the right side, she was told that a temporary couldn't be made because it wasn't clear whether the teeth 'scheduled' for treatment would even last. She was also told that nothing could be done for the left side until she could chew on the right, and that the fourth tooth, still mid-treatment, might have to be extracted because medication left over from an earlier treatment wouldn't come out—so she should start thinking about an implant, too. When I examined the right side myself, the visible tooth structure had indeed broken down considerably, but the roots were perfectly sound; there was no basis whatsoever for saying they 'wouldn't last.' Since both sides had simply been left in a state where she couldn't chew, I first made a bridge-style temporary using the fifth and seventh teeth on the right (in about twenty minutes), then made a temporary for the fourth tooth as well, partly for the sake of appearance, before finally beginning root canal treatment. What became clear at that point was this: what exactly had those several months of 'treatment' actually accomplished? There was no sign the canal had ever been enlarged, and it certainly hadn't been opened anywhere near the apex. The patient had been complaining of pain the entire time, yet all that had been done was swapping out the medication inside—leading me to suspect that the previous dentist was simply waiting to declare the prognosis poor and recommend extraction. And, right on cue, comes the standard recommendation for an implant. I always find myself wondering: if a dentist can't even manage routine root canal treatment properly, why would they think themselves capable of a far riskier procedure? It's true that extracting the tooth and placing an implant brings in four or five times the fee compared to patiently completing root canal treatment and fitting a private-pay crown—and it takes far less chair time, too. But is prioritizing profit to the point of issuing a false diagnosis not, in itself, a betrayal of what it means to hold a dental license? That dentist must have known that making a temporary would reveal just how sound the tooth really was, and that once root canal treatment resolved the pain, there would be no choice but to preserve the tooth—at which point the possibility of an implant would simply disappear. That someone could avoid reaching that conclusion while putting a patient through months of needless pain is, frankly, astonishing. To be fair, this particular patient did have a low tolerance for pain, and getting the canal open all the way to the apex was genuinely difficult.

Normally, when the apex of a root is still vital, it's surrounded by the jawbone (the alveolar bone), so there shouldn't be any spontaneous pain or tenderness when tapped. Yet—perhaps because the nerve had already been partially removed—she kept reporting discomfort, and once I removed the nerve entirely, the pain vanished as if it had never been there. That said, treating this single premolar took roughly five hours in total, and I honestly don't know how many other clinics would be willing to spend that much time and patience on it. The hourly return on that kind of work is simply too low.

From the patient's side, my advice is simple: don't hesitate to ask about anything you don't understand. A dentist who lacks confidence, or who resorts to half-truths, will eventually contradict themselves, which makes it easier to tell. And rather than continuing to visit a clinic you've come to distrust, it's wiser to seek a second opinion elsewhere. As for the patient in this story, she showed signs of somewhat vague, wide-ranging complaints, reporting discomfort in several places at once, and—despite having already spent a long time at her previous clinic—was quite sensitive to treatment, which slowed the pace considerably. Taking all of this together, I find myself all the more convinced that balanced treatment has to begin with real communication between doctor and patient.

Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi