Director's Column

Director's Column vol.13: Amid Inflation

Even though my days are spent absorbed in the minute repairs of the inside of the mouth, that doesn't mean I'm untouched by the wider world beyond it—nor, frankly, can I afford to be indifferent to it. The environment surrounding dentists and the dental industry as a whole has been changing rapidly. Take material costs, to begin with. Metal prices have been climbing steadily ever since I opened this clinic thirteen years ago. The main precious metals we rely on are gold, platinum, and palladium, and the increases have been especially sharp lately because of deliberate production controls by Russia, a major producer. Making a full-coverage crown for a molar out of gold or platinum takes roughly 4 to 5 grams of metal. At today's price of just under ¥4,000 per gram, that puts the metal alone at ¥15,000–¥20,000, and once the private-pay lab fee is added, the total charge comes to roughly ¥21,000–¥30,000. Metal used to cost about half what it does now, which meant we could offer a crown for ¥40,000; today, even at ¥60,000–¥70,000, the profit margin is poor. As a result, metal-bonded (porcelain-fused-to-metal) crowns—so-called ceramic teeth, which use comparatively little metal—now often work out cheaper overall than an all-metal crown, even though their lab fees run higher. In fact, in cases with some gum recession that leaves more of the crown showing, or with gaps between the teeth, an all-metal crown may not really be an option at all. In step with this, materials that use no rare metals whatsoever—all-ceramic, metal-bonded restorations, zirconia abutments, and the like—are turning up more and more often.

Partly because of the deflationary years following the collapse of the bubble economy, the average price of a metal-bonded crown settled at around ¥100,000, and if anything, there was a gradual drift toward lower prices. Lately, though, things have grown more chaotic. The overwhelming majority of dental labs are run by a single technician working alone, which makes it hard for them to improve efficiency or compete on price. Labs with several technicians on staff can divide the work and operate more efficiently, but that division of labor also tends to dilute any one technician's sense of responsibility for an individual piece—something plenty of dentists dislike—and in any case, such labs don't seem particularly inclined to compete on low prices either. As a result, lab fees have historically stayed fairly close together across the industry. Lately, though, labs charging less than half the going rate have begun to appear: labs based in China. Backed by comparatively low labor costs and large teams of technicians, they are mounting an aggressive low-price campaign. They claim Japanese technicians oversee the work to maintain quality, and that they use exactly the metals specified, but there's no real way to confirm any of it. They have moved beyond the higher-margin private-pay restorations and are now taking on NHI (insurance-covered) lab work as well, which has technicians here deeply worried, even as regulators have yet to address the issue. In response, some of the larger domestic labs have begun similar price-cutting moves of their own. Among dentists, perhaps owing to a generally conservative mindset, only a minority have actually adopted these cheaper labs. But realistically, there isn't much difference in the finished quality of a metal-bonded crown whether the lab fee is ¥5,000 or ¥10,000. If anything, seeing how these newer, lower-cost labs tend to be quicker on their feet and more willing to redo work without complaint, I find myself wondering whether it wouldn't actually make more sense to pass the savings on, price our private-pay work below what other clinics charge, and win broader satisfaction from patients that way. Perhaps I'm alone in thinking so.

Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi