Director's Column

Director's Column vol.12: Dentures, Bridges, Implants (Part 3)

Last time, I discussed the options for a single missing tooth; this time, let's consider what happens when several teeth are missing. As I mentioned before, once both of the back molars are lost, a bridge is no longer an option, since there's nothing further back left to support it. With a denture, the natural approach would be to hook clasps onto the two premolars and make a smaller partial denture, but this tends not to hold up well: the two clasped teeth typically end up bearing too much load and start to loosen. To prevent that, a connecting bar is extended across to the other side of the arch so the clasp can be anchored there as well. Naturally, that bar has a noticeable, foreign presence in the mouth, which is a real hurdle for anyone using a denture for the first time. It also looks less attractive and tends to trap food debris, and because some of the biting force is transferred onto the gum tissue itself, it can cause its own discomfort. An implant avoids all of these drawbacks. In this scenario, placing two implants can restore both the bite and the appearance. Placing a single implant at the very back and using the fifth tooth (the second premolar) as a bridge abutment is also technically possible, but the prognosis for that approach is considered poor, though it should be said there isn't a firm consensus on the point.

The cost of an implant varies somewhat, but generally runs from about ¥350,000 to ¥450,000 per tooth. In the case just described, that comes to a total of ¥700,000 to ¥900,000, which I imagine is only within reach for a limited number of patients. Even so, the number of people who want implants keeps steadily growing.

When three or more teeth are missing, it's common to splint several teeth together with a single bridge. The advantages here are that even a somewhat loose tooth can be stabilized once it's connected to its neighbors, easing the load on any one tooth, and that fitting a bridge requires aligning the teeth along the arch, which tends to leave the bite both tidier-looking and easier to chew with. The drawbacks are that the dummy (pontic) sections are hard to clean, and that straightening a crooked bite to accommodate the bridge often means the nerve has to be removed from certain teeth. There is also the issue that if even one abutment tooth later fails, the entire bridge usually has to come out. When a patient has lost many teeth, or has teeth that can't be saved, the underlying cause is usually one of three things: advanced decay that has reached the root, a fractured root, or advanced gum disease (pyorrhea). There's no easy way to break the news to a patient that several teeth need to come out, but with a denture, you can keep the number of extractions to a minimum, position the clasps with an eye toward which teeth are likely to fail down the road, and simply add teeth to the denture as they're lost. No other treatment offers that kind of flexibility. Implants, by comparison, offer far less. At best, you can reduce the number of implants placed across a span of missing teeth, since connecting an implant to a natural tooth is generally contraindicated. If a tooth is already loose, you cannot place an implant on the assumption that the loose tooth will eventually be lost; the natural approach is to place the implant only once that tooth has actually come out. And once you commit to implants, every subsequent tooth lost in that same area essentially has to be replaced with another implant as well. Looked at this way, the deciding factor becomes how long a patient's finances can keep up—and if the benefits of this treatment end up available only to a limited group of people, it raises a real question about where its value actually lies, one that gives me, as a dentist, plenty to think about regarding my own position.

Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi