Hobby Column

Front Row: It's Only the End of the World (Dolan), Part 2

◆ Who Is Louis, Really?

Afterward, Suzanne invites Louis into her room. There we learn that Louis has always made a point of sending a postcard for every family member's birthday — postcards that anyone could pick up and read. As if to make up for his long absence, they held nothing secret or personal meant for any one person in particular. They were, you might say, a dutiful, ready-made kind of memory-making.

At their mother's call, the two go into the kitchen, where she brings up the old story of their once-regular ‘Sunday drives.’ In her memory, it isn't their father but Antoine who carries young Louis on his shoulders across the fields — from which we can infer that, before Louis left home, the two brothers were once close. Then, perhaps thanks to the wine, there's a scene where Louis throws up in the bathroom, then calls someone who seems to be his lover and tells him he still hasn't said anything.

Right after that, coming out of the bathroom, he runs straight into Catherine, and, almost without meaning to, Louis says:

‘I'm sorry my brother says such unkind things. He's practically trying to make you hate me.’

The words just come out. Catherine answers him plainly and firmly:

‘He hardly ever talks about you. He thinks you have no interest at all in him or the rest of us. Do you even know what kind of work he does? He works at a factory that makes tools.’

Louis starts to explain why he's come, but Catherine cuts him off, telling him it isn't her place to hear it. Louis, unable to give any real answer, can only stand there smiling.

Watching up to this point, something interesting comes into focus. Against a story that unfolds almost entirely through conversation —

— for almost the entire time, Louis keeps his right hand toward the window. Since it's daytime indoors, no one bothers turning the lights on even though the room is dim, so the right side of Louis's face reads bright while the left falls into shadow, hard to make out clearly. Does that mean the person he's talking to is shown the same way, with only their left side visible? No, it isn't like that at all. Even allowing for some difference in shading, we can still read the expression on both sides of their face. Isn't this precisely the duality of Louis that Dolan wanted to capture?

He has crossed a twelve-year gap to come to his family and tell them of his own death. But that gap is far too wide, and the family can't get close to the real Louis — the one they've only known through newspapers and magazines. On top of that, each of them unloads their own twisted feelings onto him, which makes it that much harder for Louis to speak honestly. And through these conversations, we come to realize that Louis, in truth, doesn't have much real interest in his family either. Twice he tries to say what he really means, only to have someone change the subject. This too is a mark of Dolan's skill as a storyteller: surely some of the family sense, on some level, that whatever Louis has to say will only cause them pain. And since Louis isn't eager to say it either, things end up smoothed over with a friendly smile and a few passing words. It's this ambiguous stance of his that the shadow across his face is used to express.

Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi