- Home
- Hobby Column
- Front Row: Laurence Anyways (Dolan), Part 8
Front Row: Laurence Anyways (Dolan), Part 8
◆ What Does the Homage to Marlon Brando in A Streetcar Named Desire Mean?
In a bonus feature included on the disc, Xavier Dolan says that he is paying homage to Marlon Brando in A Streetcar Named Desire — the film version of Tennessee Williams's famous play. The play had run on both Broadway and in London, and when Elia Kazan came to direct the film, he brought over Vivien Leigh (as Blanche) from the London production, while casting Marlon Brando (as Stanley) and the rest from Broadway.
Blanche comes to New Orleans to lean on her younger sister, Stella. She boards a streetcar named Desire, transfers to one called Cemeteries, and gets off at Elysian Fields. The two sisters were raised in a wealthy household, but the family has since fallen on hard times, and Stella is now living with Stanley, a factory worker. He's coarse, fond of gambling, and has no patience for Blanche's prim, affected airs.
One day, after a violent argument between husband and wife, Stella and Blanche take refuge upstairs at a friend's apartment. Stanley comes home drunk and, in a shameless, disheveled state, begs and wails for Stella to come back to him. Worn down, Stella finally goes back downstairs to him — for no reason other than the fact that he gives her a pleasure that borders on madness, and she knows it. Stanley understands this perfectly well, and feels no doubt at all that his selfish desire will soon be satisfied.
This is remarkably close to Laurence's attitude toward Fred. He pays no mind whatsoever to Fred's husband or her son, and he's exactly the same way toward his own understanding young girlfriend. This is probably Dolan's own view of love: that to love someone is, in itself, an inherently selfish act.
When I spoke with Asami Shibuya, whom I mentioned in an earlier post, she made an interesting observation — that the film shows us Laurence in any number of vivid individual moments, but that it's surprisingly hard to draw those moments together into a coherent whole. I had much the same impression myself. So where does that difficulty come from?
If you think of it as a piece of weaving, the warp thread might be Laurence — who has gender identity disorder — coming out, enduring society's punishment for it, and gradually making a name for himself as a writer; and the weft thread might be Fred, cycling through understanding, estrangement, and reunion as her lover Laurence transforms. But taken that way alone, I don't think Laurence himself ever quite comes into focus. I suspect the reason this film, well-regarded as it is, still leaves you with a faint, hard-to-scratch itch is that people are generally looking in the wrong place when they try to understand Laurence as a person. At the risk of being misunderstood, let me say it plainly: Laurence is, frankly, kind of a bad guy. His obliviousness during the café scene I mentioned earlier, and the way he talked Fred into running off to L'Île au Noir — in both, you can catch a glimpse of Stanley's character from A Streetcar Named Desire. Understand that, I think, and all those separate points about Laurence finally join up into a line.
Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi