- Home
- Director's Column
- Director's Column vol.5 ● Inside the Mouth: A Black Box, Part 1
Director's Column vol.5 ● Inside the Mouth: A Black Box, Part 1
Quite a few people, I imagine, have had the experience of being treated at a dental clinic that doesn't explain much, and coming away not knowing what was actually done inside their own mouth — in other words, having their mouth become a black box. Informed consent (explaining the content of treatment and obtaining the patient's agreement) has been talked about for a long time now, but it's often neglected once a dentist gets caught up in simply processing patients one after another. Looking at treatment topic by topic, I think there's real value in knowing what does, or doesn't, happen inside that black box. The first thing I want to take up is root canal treatment — treatment of the root. When a tooth hurts, the cause generally falls into one of three categories: a cavity (a living tooth), the root tip (a dead tooth, from a previous treatment with a poor outcome), or a periodontal pocket (the groove between the tooth and gum). When a cavity is large and the tooth is sensitive to both hot and cold, and after examining the extent of it I judge that the tooth can't be saved, I perform pulpectomy under anesthesia (removing the living nerve). At this point, how much pain a person feels varies enormously and is, to a real degree, subjective. In my own practice, most of the teeth I end up removing the nerve from are so broken down that they've lost their original shape; I won't remove the nerve for a small chip, and honestly, I won't remove it even for a fairly large chip. Likewise, even if the pulp is exposed at a single point (meaning the nerve is showing and bleeding), if the tooth structure around it is otherwise healthy, I'll often disinfect it thoroughly, cover it with cement, and keep it under observation, doing conservative treatment rather than jumping straight to removing the nerve. If you're told the nerve needs to come out right away, it's worth asking to see exactly what shape the tooth is in, and if you're not convinced, you're within your rights to stop treatment there and seek a second opinion elsewhere. At the risk of being misunderstood, let me say it plainly: if all you have is sensitivity to cold, the likelihood that you actually need the nerve removed is extremely low.
Pulpectomy is, in essence, the treatment of removing the nerve as cleanly as possible all the way to the tip of the root canal, then widening that space and rendering it sterile. For this, an apex locator (a device for measuring canal length) is essential — used properly, it allows you to get within about 0.5mm of the root apex. Since there's no inflammation at the root tip in these cases, once the canal has been widened sufficiently it's simply filled — but canals vary enormously in shape and width from one tooth to the next, so smoothing out the inside of the canal with a reamer (a widening instrument) is really where a dentist's hand skill shows. It does take a certain amount of time, though, which patients tend not to enjoy. Still, this isn't a place to cut corners: if the outcome turns out poorly, no matter how fine the crown placed on top may be, it will eventually have to come off.
When a tooth that has already had root canal treatment hurts on biting, or the area around the root tip starts to swell, and an X-ray shows a dark shadow there, the crown and core are removed and the tooth undergoes treatment for an infected root canal. The difference from the case above is that the tooth is already dead, and there's active inflammation at the root tip. Since it has to be assumed that the inside of the canal is contaminated, the main goal is to remove the old root-filling material and the contaminated tooth structure, place a strong antibacterial medication, and work toward a sterile state. Inflammation often remains at the root tip even so, and the treatment period frequently ends up longer than expected. It amounts to cleaning up after another dentist's work, but it's also exactly the kind of case where it's important not to take the easy way out. Has the inside of the black box become a little clearer to you now?
Igarashi Dental Clinic | Shimbashi, Tokyo
Director Atsuo Igarashi